Back to Blog
••10 min read

Gamma vs Scholarly: An Honest AI Slide Generator Comparison

Gamma vs Scholarly for turning lecture notes or a PDF into slides: where Gamma wins on design and editing, where Scholarly wins, and when to use Plus AI.

By ScholarlyComparison
Share:
Gamma vs Scholarly: An Honest AI Slide Generator Comparison editorial illustration

What is the best AI tool to turn lecture notes or a PDF into slides?

Use Gamma if you want a designed deck you can keep editing by hand. Use Scholarly if you want to present straight from your source with speaker notes on every slide, then turn the same material into a lecture, a podcast, or flashcards. Gamma wins on design control, editing, and collaboration, and its Free plan gives you 400 one-time credits. Scholarly's Free plan makes one 10-slide deck for life, to present and share by link; downloads are paid, and in its PowerPoint export the slide visuals are images, so you cannot edit the text inside them.

If the deck must live in PowerPoint or Google Slides, look at Plus AI (native slides, no free plan, uploads from its Pro plan) or Copilot in PowerPoint (a Word file on home plans; a PDF needs a work license).

Disclosure: Scholarly is our product, and we make a competing slide generator. Gamma facts below come from Gamma's help center, read on October 30, 2026. We link Gamma's pricing page rather than quote prices, because they change.

Gamma vs Scholarly at a glance

Gamma Scholarly
Best at Design, templates, editing by hand A deck and its talk from your source, then more from the same source
Starts from Prompt, PDF, Word, PowerPoint, web link, pasted text, spreadsheet data PDF, Word, PowerPoint, spreadsheet, notes, web link, Google Drive file, or a topic
Free plan 400 one-time credits; 200 more per referral 1 lifetime AI creation: one 10-slide deck from one upload (8 MB, first 32 PDF pages)
Free export PDF, PNG, PowerPoint; PDF and PowerPoint carry a badge None: present and share by link
Speaker notes Yes; its help page describes adding them yourself Yes, written from your source on every slide
Editing Full editor, plus AI edits Edit text before the build (paid); Refine or side chat afterward
PowerPoint export Yes; tables stay editable Paid; slide visuals are images, notes are in the notes pane
Co-editing Yes; links can allow view, comment, or edit No; viewing links only
Beyond slides Documents, webpages, social posts, graphics Video lectures, podcasts, flashcards, quizzes, practice exams, chat

Working from a PDF or notes

Both tools can work from your file, and this is where older comparisons, including an earlier version of this one, are out of date.

Gamma imports .pptx, .docx, and PDF files, and lets you decide what happens to your words. You can import a file with its layout and structure intact, or use it as source material for something new. You can tell the agent "Keep my text exactly as written," and the classic generator has a Preserve option. So Gamma does not have to rewrite your content, as long as you ask.

Scholarly always builds from the source you give it. It reads the file, including figures and tables where the PDF has them, writes the talk first, and then designs each slide to fit. You can limit a long PDF to the pages you need. You get a new deck rather than a restyled copy of your pages. The PDF to slides tool is the starting point.

Which is better: if you already have good slides or finished text, Gamma's preserve options fit. If you have a chapter or a stack of notes and need it turned into a talk, Scholarly does that work for you. Neither is reliable enough to present from without reading. Check numbers, names, and diagrams against the source.

Design and templates

Gamma wins. Design is what the product is built around: themes, a template system, custom themes, and an editor where you can change anything. It also supports posters, social carousels, documents, and webpages.

Scholarly has no template library and no slide-by-slide design editor. You choose a preset (Full Deck or Exam Prep), a color look or Auto, dark mode, and an optional expert style such as Minimalist Keynote or Visual Teaching Deck, and it picks a shape for each slide. The result is clean and consistent, with typeset equations and real charts, but you have far less control. If your deck is a pitch or a marketing piece, use Gamma.

Speaker notes

Both have them, and they work differently.

Gamma's help page describes typing notes into a panel and reading them in Presenter View, with a timer. Notes are included in PowerPoint and Google Slides exports. The help page does not describe the AI writing notes on every slide.

Scholarly writes them for you. The AI writes the talk first and attaches it to the slides, so each slide has what to say, the detail behind it, and the figures to quote. On a paid plan, the PowerPoint download puts them in the notes pane, ready for Presenter View.

If you want to walk in with a talk already drafted from your document, this is the strongest reason to pick Scholarly.

Editing

Gamma wins. You edit text, images, and layouts directly, and you can ask its AI to change a slide. A manual edit uses no credits.

Scholarly is built to give you a finished deck rather than a canvas. On a paid plan you can edit slide text before the build. Afterward, you request changes with Refine or the side chat. You do not drag things around on a slide.

Exports

  • Gamma: PDF, PNG, and PowerPoint, on every plan. For Google Slides, upload the .pptx. Tables stay editable in PowerPoint. On Free, PDF and PowerPoint exports carry a "Made by Gamma" badge, and paid plans remove it.
  • Scholarly: on Free, you present in the browser and share a view link, with no download. On paid plans, you can export PDF, PowerPoint, Word, Google Slides, Google Docs, and print. In PowerPoint and Google Slides, the slide visuals are images, so the text inside them cannot be edited there. The Word and Google Docs versions stay editable as text.

If you need a PowerPoint file you can restyle slide by slide, Gamma or Plus AI is the better tool.

What it costs

Gamma: new Free users get 400 credits, and they do not refresh. Credits are metered per slide and per image. You can earn 200 per referral, up to 2,000 at a time. Paid plans (Plus, Pro, Ultra, and team plans) refill monthly. See Gamma's pricing.

Scholarly: Free is 1 lifetime AI Creation, shared across slides, flashcards, podcasts, videos, and the other tools, and it does not reset. Premium costs $30 a month or $180 a year and includes 15 AI Creation Credits a week; Laureate costs $99 a month and includes 80. One deck uses 1 AI Creation Credit on the default model. See pricing.

If all you need is slides, compare Gamma's plans first. Scholarly costs more to justify on slides alone. It makes sense when you would also use the lectures, podcasts, flashcards, or practice exams.

Collaboration

Gamma: you can share with others to view, comment, or edit, and workspace options depend on your plan. If several people are building a deck together, Gamma is the better tool.

Scholarly: generated decks are shared by link for viewing, with no co-editing. Teams get a shared library and roles, but not real-time editing of a deck.

After the deck

Gamma covers decks, documents, webpages, and graphics. The presentation is the end product.

Scholarly treats the deck as one output from a source you keep. The same upload can also become:

For a student, that means a textbook chapter can become slides for a study group, flashcards for yourself, and a practice exam for the day before the test. For a trainer, an SOP can become a deck, a video, and a quiz. If you only need a deck, none of this matters, and Gamma is the simpler choice.

On a phone

Gamma: its iOS and Android app is available in the US and Canada, and you edit there through its agent rather than by hand. In a mobile browser, its help says it starts in Express mode.

Scholarly: it runs in your phone's browser with nothing to install, and there is no app in the App Store or Google Play. Slides View works on a phone for reviewing and presenting. Look and dark mode are desktop settings.

Where Plus AI and Copilot fit

Both of these work inside the app you present from, which neither Gamma nor Scholarly does.

For a full ranking, read the best AI slide generators in 2026. For the PowerPoint route specifically, see Copilot in PowerPoint vs Scholarly.

Which should you pick?

Pick Gamma if:

  • The look of the deck matters, as with a pitch, a marketing deck, or a portfolio.
  • You will edit slides by hand or with other people.
  • You want an editable PowerPoint file.
  • You want to try it several times for free.

Pick Scholarly if:

  • You want a talk drafted from your source, with notes on every slide.
  • The deck comes from a chapter, a paper, an SOP, or a report you also need to learn or teach.
  • You want a lecture, a podcast, or flashcards from the same upload.

The fairest test is to run the same source through both. Gamma's free credits and Scholarly's one free AI Creation are enough to judge the output you care about.

Frequently asked questions

Is Gamma or Scholarly better for lecture notes?

For a polished class presentation you will edit, Gamma. For a deck with a drafted talk, followed by flashcards or a practice exam from the same notes, Scholarly.

Are they free?

Both have free plans with limits. Gamma gives 400 one-time credits, and free exports carry a badge. Scholarly gives one lifetime AI creation, which can be one 10-slide deck from one upload, with no download. Neither allowance refreshes.

Does Gamma keep my text from a PDF?

It can. Gamma's help says PDF imports keep your layout and structure, and you can tell it to keep your text exactly as written.

Can I edit Scholarly slides in PowerPoint?

Partly. On a paid plan, the .pptx holds your notes and slide order, but each slide's visual is a picture, so its text stays fixed. Use the Word or Google Docs copy for editable text.

Does either one have speaker notes?

Yes. Gamma's help describes adding notes yourself, and they carry into its PowerPoint export. Scholarly writes notes from your source on every slide.

Related tools