Made with ScholarlyMake flashcards like these from your own notes
Question:How does Shearer define the central body of international law?
Answer:It is a body of principles and rules of conduct that States feel bound to observe and commonly observe in their relations with one another.
Question:How does the SS Lotus Case define international law’s basis between States?
Answer:Rules binding independent States emanate from their own will, expressed in conventions or usages generally accepted as law, to regulate their relations or achieve common aims.
Question:Which actors and relationships fall within the Restatement definition of international law?
Answer:It covers rules and principles of general application concerning State conduct, international organisations, their relations with one another, and some relations with natural or juridical persons.
Question:How does the US Department of State definition portray international law’s development?
Answer:It describes international law as continually changing and developing. Its evolution may be gradual or abrupt, and customary rules can be obligatory or non-obligatory depending on the subject matter and its status at a particular time.
Question:Which two principles underpinned the earliest recorded treaties?
Answer:Pacta sunt servanda (agreements must be kept) and the principle of good faith.
Question:Which two distinctive practices did Ancient Greece add to diplomacy and treaty-making?
Answer:International arbitration and proxeny (State hospitality), which lay at the origin of consular protection for foreigners.
Question:How did Greek rules regulate conduct during war?
Answer:War was to be avoided and begun only by declaration. Heralds were not to be harmed, soldiers killed in battle were entitled to burial, people sheltering in captured temples were to be spared, prisoners were to be ransomed or exchanged rather than killed, and priests and seers were exempt.
Question:What did the Roman concept of jus fetiale govern?
Answer:Religious rules governing Rome’s external relations and formal declarations of war. It recognised the inviolability of ambassadors and contributed to the distinction between just and unjust war.
Question:What legal relationships did jus gentium regulate in Roman law?
Answer:It governed relations between Roman citizens and foreigners. It became an important part of Roman law and influenced European legal systems and public international law.
Question:How does natural law explain the universality of law?
Answer:It treats law as right reason inherent in nature and humanity, discoverable by reason. Because it is universal, it applies to all nations and all times.
Question:What problem led medieval merchants to create lex mercatoria?
Answer:Cross-border trade required a common legal framework. Merchants developed their own rules of conduct and fair dealing, enforced through special courts that decided commercial disputes.
Question:Why did maritime customary rules develop during the Middle Ages?
Answer:Growing maritime commerce created a need for rules and standards for the sea. Customs were codified in collections that became accepted throughout Europe.
Question:Which principles did the Treaty of Westphalia recognise?
Answer:Sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the equality of States. It also recognised non-interference in a State’s affairs and the State’s independence from the Church.
Question:What limits did territorial boundaries place on State sovereignty?
Answer:A State’s authority did not extend beyond its finite territory and boundaries. Other sovereign States existed beyond those limits, so States needed rules to govern their relationships.
Question:What was the purpose of the balance-of-power system established under Westphalia?
Answer:It aimed to prevent wars by ensuring that no European State became more powerful than the others. The system was later readopted by the Congress of Vienna.
Question:How did late-eighteenth-century events influence human rights and self-determination?
Answer:Enlightenment ideals associated with the North American colonies’ struggle for independence and the French Revolution influenced the development of human rights and the principle of self-determination.
Question:What argument did Grotius make for freedom of the seas?
Answer:He argued that no country could monopolise control over the ocean because of its immensity, lack of stability, and lack of fixed limits.
Question:How did Grotius describe a just war and its conduct?
Answer:He described a just war as a war to obtain a right and treated it as punitive action against State crimes when conciliation had failed. He emphasised moral conduct, including protection of non-combatants, humane treatment of hostages and prisoners, and protection of property from wanton destruction.
Question:What does the concept of State reason permit in a conflict between law and State interests?
Answer:It holds that preserving State power or the State against external enemies may prevail over law and morals when the conflict is irreconcilable. It has been used to justify reneging on binding international obligations.
Question:What was the Congress of Vienna’s main political objective?
Answer:It sought a new balance of political forces in Europe to ensure lasting peace and maintain the status quo, including through territorial arrangements that would prevent any one State from becoming dominant.
Question:How did the Concert of Europe attempt to preserve peace?
Answer:The powers agreed to meet periodically to discuss common problems and cooperate on major issues. The Concert became an international mechanism for maintaining peace and was largely successful in preserving peace in Europe for almost a century.
Question:What did the Congress of Vienna codify or promote beyond the balance of power?
Answer:It codified law on diplomatic agents and missions, prohibited slave trading, and laid foundations for free navigation of rivers flowing through at least two European States.
Question:Which States were treated as subjects of international law during 1815–1914?
Answer:States were recognised as the only subjects of international law.
Question:How was war viewed as an instrument during 1815–1914?
Answer:War was accepted as the ultimate instrument for enforcing law and safeguarding national honour and interests.
Question:What argument challenges international law’s status as law?
Answer:The challenge is that international law lacks a legislature, judiciary, or executive, in the usual sense, to create, interpret, and enforce it.
Question:What practical evidence supports treating international law as law?
Answer:States recognise and observe it, contributing to substantial order in international relations. International lawyers, intergovernmental organisations, other non-State actors, and domestic and international courts apply it.
Question:Why might a State comply with international law for long-term advantage?
Answer:The prospective long-term advantage of compliance may prevail over any short-term advantage gained by violating international law.
Question:How can reputation and reciprocity encourage State compliance?
Answer:A State may seek to maintain its good reputation and fear retaliatory or reciprocal measures by a victim State if it violates international law.
Question:How can the UN Security Council enforce international law?
Answer:Under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, the Security Council may take various measures, including the use of force, to compel a State to comply.
Question:How can treaties require States to resolve disputes?
Answer:Treaties may bind States to accept the compulsory jurisdiction and judgments of a body established by treaty to handle disputes arising under it.
Question:Which serious violations fall within the International Criminal Court’s stated jurisdiction?
Answer:The ICC has jurisdiction to prosecute and punish individuals responsible for the most serious violations of human rights law and international humanitarian law.
Question:How does international law facilitate cooperation between States?
Answer:States are interdependent in many ways, and international law facilitates their cooperation.
Question:How can international law help States manage coexistence?
Answer:It can help States define their relationships by making treaties and other consensual agreements.
Question:What two functions does international law serve during conflict?
Answer:It prescribes technical rules of conduct and helps keep conflict to a minimum.
Question:Which features characterized the classical system of international law?
Answer:Sovereign States were its sole subjects. The international community was unorganised, and war was accepted as the ultimate means of enforcing law and safeguarding national interests.
Question:Which three stages did Auguste Comte propose for human development?
Answer:The theological stage focused on religious ideas; the metaphysical stage on legalistic and jurisprudential ideas; and the positive stage on objectively ascertainable facts through science.
Question:How did John Austin define laws properly so called?
Answer:They are commands of a sovereign who receives obedience from members of an independent political society and owes obedience to no other person.
Question:Why did Austin classify international law as improperly so called?
Answer:International law is not commanded by a sovereign, so it fails his test for positive law and falls outside laws properly so called.
Question:How does international law differ structurally from municipal law?
Answer:Municipal law is vertical: it governs relations between a sovereign and citizens through coercion. International law is horizontal: it regulates relations between equal, independent States and is decentralised.
Question:How did H.L.A. Hart distinguish primary from secondary rules?
Answer:Primary rules impose duties. Secondary rules include rules of recognition, rules of change, and rules of adjudication.
Question:What function does Hart’s rule of recognition serve?
Answer:It provides a way to identify the system’s primary rules.
Question:What do Hart’s rules of change allow a legal system to do?
Answer:They provide a mechanism to introduce new rules and change or abolish old rules.
Question:What role do Hart’s rules of adjudication perform?
Answer:They provide for compulsory adjudication of disputes by courts and other bodies.
Question:Why did Hart describe international law as a primitive legal order?
Answer:He argued that institutional limitations had prevented it from developing secondary rules, particularly because it lacked a legislature and compulsory jurisdiction for international courts.
Question:How are Hart’s three secondary-rule functions reflected internationally?
Answer:The rule of recognition is incorporated in the ICJ Statute. Rules of change operate through treaties and customary law. Treaties provide for some compulsory jurisdiction of international courts, tribunals, and other bodies.
Question:Which practical considerations matter when assessing international law?
Answer:Henkin emphasizes whether international law is reflected in national policies and relations between States, adapts to the international community’s changing needs, guides dispute settlement, and is observed by States.
Question:Why do visible international-law breaches not establish that the law is ineffective or nonexistent?
Answer:Breaches can be more conspicuous than compliance, and enforcement is distinct from the existence of law. Rules may be obeyed because they are regarded as right, just, and appropriate, not only from fear of punishment.
Question:How did Kelsen explain enforcement in a decentralised legal order?
Answer:Enforcement can operate through self-help: individuals injured by a delict or illegality take action, but may be regarded as acting as organs of the community.
Question:What does the account say about the UN Security Council’s enforcement role?
Answer:The UN’s enforcement powers were invigorated after the Cold War, though the UN is not a law-enforcement agency. The Security Council has found it must act in situations involving serious and persistent human-rights violations.
Question:What is the shared purpose of the hybrid criminal tribunals described?
Answer:They combine national and international judges, prosecutors, and legal rules. Their mandates are to bring to justice and punish perpetrators of crimes within their jurisdiction.
Question:What effect can a Security Council referral under Rome Statute Article 13(b) have?
Answer:The Security Council may refer an ICC situation involving crimes within the Court’s subject-matter jurisdiction, regardless of whether Article 12(2)(a) and (b) jurisdictional conditions are met. UN States must comply with the Council’s decision, including surrendering an indicted person or supplying evidence.
Question:How do the European Court of Justice and Caribbean Court of Justice relate to treaties?
Answer:The European Court of Justice interprets and applies treaties establishing the EU. The Caribbean Court of Justice applies and interprets the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas establishing the CARICOM Single Market and Economy.
Question:How can a State’s reputation encourage compliance with international law?
Answer:Reputation reflects judgments about past behaviour used to predict future behaviour. States may comply and accept enforcement judgments to appear reliable to partners.
Question:How does reciprocity encourage compliance between States?
Answer:A State may respond to another State’s agreement violation by withdrawing its own compliance, without intending to punish the other State. The approach relies on the victim State having no benefit from continued compliance.
Question:How does retaliation differ from reciprocity as a compliance strategy?
Answer:Retaliation takes action to punish the offending State and is normally costly to the retaliating State. Reciprocity withdraws compliance without an intent to punish.
Question:How can public opinion contribute to international-law compliance?
Answer:Public awareness of rights can pressure governments over breaches. Governments may also appeal to public opinion for support when another State violates international law.
Question:What does the China example illustrate about international law?
Answer:After the Cultural Revolution ended, China’s leaders chose to join the international community for better relations with other governments. The example illustrates that States need international relations and cannot afford to stand alone.
Question:Which three levels of international relations involve international law?
Answer:Co-operation, co-existence, and conflict.
Question:How does international law facilitate co-operation between States?
Answer:It supports joint action where international-scale efforts are most effective, including maintaining a postal system, eradicating disease through common vaccination rules, and combating international terrorism.
Question:What does exclusive EU power mean in the policy areas described?
Answer:For areas such as Common Commercial Policy and Common Agricultural Policy, the EU alone is entitled to act at both the internal and international levels.
Question:How can reciprocity support co-existence between States?
Answer:Treaties and consensual agreements define relationships, and reciprocity can discourage actions that might prompt other States to respond in kind. Shared interest in long-term international stability also provides an incentive for restraint.
Question:What functions does international law serve during conflict?
Answer:It prescribes technical rules of conduct and helps keep conflict to a minimum. Many rules of warfare are embodied in conventions, including the Hague and 1949 Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols.
Question:What significance does the Treaty of Westphalia have in the timeline?
Answer:The Treaty of Westphalia concluded in 1648 and is described as marking the beginning of international law between sovereign nation States.
Question:What international order did the Congress of Vienna establish?
Answer:It established a new political balance of power in Europe, based on sovereignty, territorial integrity, and equality of States, and created the Concert of Europe.
Question:What institutions emerged from the 1919 League of Nations framework?
Answer:The League of Nations and the Permanent Court of International Justice were established under the 1919 Peace Conference framework.
Question:What change to international law followed the creation of the United Nations?
Answer:After the Second World War, the United Nations introduced a new approach to international law, with enforcement powers set out in the UN Charter.
Question:What developments are associated with the end of the Cold War?
Answer:The period from the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 to the official dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991 is treated as the end of the Cold War. The period is associated with the collapse of Soviet Union policies, a victory of democracy, and a changed world political make-up.
Question:Which factors can lead a State to comply with international law?
Answer:A State may have consented to its obligations, expect long-term advantages from compliance, seek a good reputation, fear retaliation, respond to public opinion, or face proceedings in national courts when international law is part of national law.
Question:Which non-forcible measures may be taken against a State?
Answer:A victim State or an NGO may use diplomatic sanctions, potentially severing diplomatic relations. Economic or other non-forcible sanctions may be imposed unilaterally or collectively by victim States. The Security Council may also impose non-forcible sanctions under Chapter VII of the UN Charter.
Question:What forcible measure against a State is described?
Answer:The Security Council may authorise the use of force against a State under Article 42 of the UN Charter.
Question:How can psychological pressure help enforce international law?
Answer:Public condemnation of a State’s conduct may lead to private sanctions, such as a Member State and its corporations refusing to buy goods produced by that State.
Question:Which measures against individuals are described for enforcing international law?
Answer:A person may be brought before the ICC or another international criminal court. The Security Council may impose sanctions, such as asset freezes or travel bans, on individuals or identified groups. A State may impose confiscation, fines, or imprisonment under its jurisdiction, and victims may bring criminal or civil actions in national courts against foreign persons who violated international law.