Make a lecture like this from your own PDF
Drop a PDF, slides or notes here. You'll sign up, then yours starts.
0:00 / 2:54
The bunker dilemma concerns whether killing X for food after a predicted asteroid impact is murder. Although the killing is intentional and may meet the definition of murder, criminal liability requires a further sequence: legality, conduct, the definitional elements, unlawfulness, capacity, and fault. The central issue is whether a ground of justification removes unlawfulness.
South African law connects justification to the Constitution and the legal values and consensus of the community. The question is whether a reasonable, law-abiding citizen would regard the conduct as justified, but this remains a legal assessment rather than a matter of sympathy alone. Dudley and Stephens illustrates this distinction: the court rejected necessity after the accused killed an apparently innocent cabin boy.
The video then explains private defence. The attack must be unlawful, threaten a legally protected interest, and be imminent. The defensive action must target the attacker and be necessary and reasonable. In the Rosebank example, Y’s stabbing of X after X breaks into the home and threatens Y and Z may be justified, but the key questions are whether the attack was still imminent and whether lethal force was still necessary when X was struck from behind. Z’s attempt to break a window may also be justified if it was necessary and reasonable to stop the attack.
Finally, a lawful police arrest does not create an unlawful attack, while an animal cannot commit one because it cannot perform a voluntary human act; necessity may instead apply. The child-attacker issue remains unresolved and requires further authority, including the South African case Goliath, to determine whether lack of criminal capacity prevents an attack from being unlawful.
0:00Begin with the bunker dilemma. A group trapped after a predicted asteroid impact agrees to kill X and use his body for food. The starting point is the definition of murder: the intentional and unlawful causing of the death of another human being. Intentional killing may therefore satisfy the definitional elements, but unlawfulness must still be established. Criminal liability is assessed through a sequence: legality, conduct, compliance with the definitional elements, unlawfulness, capacity, and fault. Conduct that appears unlawful prima facie may be justified by the circumstances. The key question is whether a lawful ground of justification removes unlawfulness. South African law relates this inquiry to the Constitution and the legal convictions, values, and consensus of the community. The test is whether a reasonable law-abiding citizen would regard the conduct as justified. But community perception alone is not enough; the assessment is a legal one. The survival case of Dudley and Stephens shows the distinction between sympathy and justification: the court rejected necessity and convicted the accused after they killed an apparently innocent cabin boy. The bunker problem therefore requires analysis, not an automatic conclusion.
1:21Private defence is a ground of justification. Harm inflicted on an aggressor while repelling an unlawful attack is not unlawful, but the doctrine has specific requirements. The attack must be unlawful, directed at a legally protected interest, and imminent rather than completed. The defensive response must be directed at the attacker, necessary to avert the harm, and carried out with reasonable means. Apply this to Rosebank. X unlawfully breaks into Y’s home and threatens Y and Z with a crowbar. Y’s stabbing of X may potentially be private defence of person or property, but the crucial questions are whether the attack was still imminent and whether lethal force remained necessary and reasonable when X was struck from behind. Z’s breaking of the window may also be justified as intervention to avert the attack, subject to necessity and reasonableness. Compare two boundary examples. A lawful police arrest is not an unlawful attack, so private defence does not arise on that basis. An animal cannot commit an unlawful attack because criminal-law action requires a voluntary human act; necessity may instead be relevant. The source leaves the child-attacker question open. Use it as a final check: does lack of criminal capacity prevent an attack from being unlawful? The answer requires further authority, including the signposted South African case of Goliath.