Made with ScholarlyTurn your own notes into slides like these
Shared with you
SECURE 2.0 Act §601 changed SEP and SIMPLE IRA arrangements from traditional-only plans into plans that may offer Roth treatment. The change applies to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2022, and centers on three exam-tested issues: the employee’s affirmative election, different income-inclusion timing for employee versus employer contributions, and different reporting/payroll-tax treatment (slide 1).
Before SECURE 2.0, Code §408A(f) explicitly prohibited SEP arrangements and SIMPLE IRA plans from offering Roth contribution options; contributions were strictly traditional pre-tax. Section 601 repealed §408A(f) and added Code §§408(k)(7) and 408(p)(12), allowing employees to elect Roth treatment for salary-reduction, matching, and nonelective contributions (slide 2).
Roth offering is optional. Employers are not required to offer a Roth contribution election in their SEP or SIMPLE IRA plans; offering Roth treatment is discretionary for the plan sponsor (slide 3). If offered, Roth treatment requires an affirmative employee election. Contributions can never be routed to a Roth IRA automatically, and the election must be executed prior to the date the contribution is deposited (slide 3).
A plan that offers Roth designations must provide each eligible participant an “effective opportunity” to make or modify the election at least once per calendar year (slide 3). The election must occur before the relevant funding event: before salary reduction or employer deposit in a SIMPLE IRA plan; before the wage payment date for a SARSEP; and before funding an employer allocation in a non-SARSEP SEP (slide 4).
Employer Alpha uses automatic enrollment at 3% of pay and wants all default deferrals to go into a Roth IRA unless an employee opts out. The answer is no: automatic-enrollment contributions cannot be designated as Roth IRA contributions. Without an affirmative employee election designating the contribution as Roth, default contributions must go to a traditional pre-tax IRA (slide 5).
Timing comparison: contribution made in January 2024 for the 2023 tax year. An employee deferral earned in December 2023 but deposited in January 2024 is included in 2023 gross income because that is the year the wages were earned or payable. An employer match deposited in January 2024 for the 2023 plan year is included in 2024 gross income because that is the year the contribution was actually made (slide 7).
Classification checkpoint. For an employee’s $4,000 Roth deferral, income inclusion occurs in the year wages are earned; reporting is on Form W-2 using Box 12 Code S or F; and FICA, FUTA, and FIT withholding apply. For an employer’s $2,000 Roth match, income inclusion occurs in the year deposited; reporting is on Form 1099-R using Boxes 1 and 2a and Code 2 or 7; and the contribution is excluded from FICA, FUTA, and withholding (slide 10).
Roth salary-reduction contributions are included in gross income for the taxable year in which the employee “would otherwise have received the wages in cash,” regardless of when the contribution is deposited (slide 7). They are reported on Form W-2 for the year of wage inclusion. The contribution is included in W-2 Box 1, Box 3, and Box 5 (slide 8).
For Form W-2 Box 12, use Code S for Roth elective deferrals under a SIMPLE IRA plan and Code F for Roth elective deferrals under a SARSEP plan (slide 8). The slide’s illustration shows $60,000 in Boxes 1, 3, and 5, with a $5,000 Roth deferral identified in Box 12 by Code S or Code F (slide 8).
Roth employer matching and nonelective contributions are included in gross income for the taxable year in which the contribution is “actually made/deposited into the Roth IRA” (slide 7). They are not reported on Form W-2; instead, they are reported on Form 1099-R for the year deposited (slide 9).
For Form 1099-R reporting, Box 1 (Gross distribution) shows the total employer Roth contribution, Box 2a (Taxable amount) shows the same amount as Box 1, and Box 7 uses Code 2 (“Early distribution, exception applies”) or Code 7 (“Normal distribution”). The IRA/SEP/SIMPLE checkbox must be checked (slide 9). The slide’s example reports $3,000 in both Box 1 and Box 2a (slide 9).
The two contribution streams have opposite payroll-tax treatment (slides 6, 10). Salary-reduction deferrals are subject to income tax withholding (FIT), FICA, and FUTA. Employer matching and nonelective contributions are excluded from income tax withholding, FICA, and FUTA—even though they are included in gross income (slide 11).
Because employer Roth contributions are included in gross income but excluded from withholding, employees may need to increase estimated tax payments or adjust W-4 withholding to avoid underpayment penalties (slide 11).
Be able to:
Remember the sequence: elect first, classify the stream, determine the year, choose the form, apply payroll taxes. Employee deferral means wage year → W-2 → FICA/FUTA/FIT apply. Employer match or nonelective contribution means deposit year → 1099-R → FICA/FUTA/withholding excluded (slides 7-12).
Make from this