Made with ScholarlyTurn your own files into documents like this
Criminal Psychology Unit 1 — Point-wise Notes
Module overview
Introduces classical and contemporary psychological theories of criminal behaviour.
Main approaches:
Psychodynamic theory: Freud and the role of the id, ego, and superego.
Behavioural/social learning theory: Skinner and Bandura.
Cognitive explanations: distortions and decision-making errors.
Biological explanations: genes, brain structures, neurotransmitters, hormones, and substances.
Emphasises evaluating the strengths and limitations of each theory.
Criminal behaviour is best understood through the interaction of individual and situational factors.
Crime and criminals
Crime does not have the same meaning everywhere.
An act may be legal in one culture and illegal in another; alcohol use is an example.
Crime is generally an act prohibited by law that affects society’s well-being.
A person is technically a criminal only after a court proves them guilty.
Context and intention matter:
Killing in war or self-defence may not be treated as murder.
Some immoral or antisocial behaviours are not crimes unless the law prohibits them.
Crime is a social construction: its definition changes with society, culture, historical period, and situation.
Laws are influenced by religion, morality, and social values.
Psychological explanations examine not only what happened but also the intention and reasons behind the behaviour.
Three broad psychological perspectives:
Biological: genes, brain structure, and chemical imbalances.
Individual/psychological: personality, mental health, and learning history.
Social/psychosocial: family, peers, environment, and society.
Sociological views of crime
Consensus view
Society is an integrated structure based on shared rules, values, and norms.
Laws represent the agreement about acceptable and unacceptable behaviour.
Crime is a violation of laws created through social consensus.
Social disapproval alone does not make an act a crime; it must be legally prohibited.
Intention affects whether an act is criminal, such as self-defence versus deliberate harm.
Morality and legality are different: some behaviours may be morally wrong without being illegal.
Definitions of crime change over time:
Homosexuality was criminalised in some societies but is now legal in many.
Prostitution and drug use vary in legal status.
Murder, rape, assault, and burglary are more consistently treated as crimes.
Criminal law protects people, property, social order, and sometimes the state; punishment may serve retribution for breaking agreed boundaries.
Conflict view
Society consists of groups competing over power, wealth, resources, and opportunities.
Inequality influences which crimes are committed and which crimes are punished.
Examples by social class:
Poor/working class: theft, burglary, assault, and murder.
Middle class: fraud, theft from employers, and white-collar crime.
Elite: corporate crime, environmental damage, and financial scandals.
The justice system may punish visible lower-class crimes more harshly while overlooking or treating elite crimes less seriously.
Became influential during the 1960s–1970s and was strongly influenced by Marxist ideas about capitalism.
Main criticism: the theory may overemphasise class and power while underexplaining individual differences.
Interactionist view and labelling theory
Crime depends on how behaviour is interpreted during social interaction.
People act according to their understanding of events, which may be mistaken or biased.
Social reactions teach people what is considered acceptable or unacceptable.
Positive reactions reinforce behaviour; negative reactions discourage it.
People judge themselves using meanings learned from others and culture.
Labelling theory argues that society partly creates crime by labelling people as criminals.
A person labelled a “criminal” or “thief” may internalise the label and continue offending.
Law and morality change as social meanings change.
The interactionist approach focuses on context, interpretation, reactions, and social labels rather than a fixed definition of crime.
Criminal and forensic psychology
There is no single universally accepted definition.
Gudjonsson and Haward (1998) gave an early, narrow definition: applied psychology concerned with collecting, examining, and presenting evidence for judicial purposes.
Limitation of the narrow definition: it focuses on police and courtroom work and ignores treatment and rehabilitation.
Wrightsman (2001) gave a broader definition: applying psychological knowledge or methods to any task faced by the legal system.
Modern criminal psychologists may work in:
Police investigations.
Court proceedings and expert testimony.
Offender assessment.
Prisons and correctional facilities.
Therapy, rehabilitation, risk assessment, and post-sentence interventions.
The field developed mainly in Europe and North America during the late nineteenth century; it is still developing in India.
Early history: memory and eyewitness testimony
James McKeen Cattell (1895): conducted early North American eyewitness-memory experiments and found that everyday recollections were often inaccurate.
Alfred Binet (1900): found that children’s testimony was affected by questioning style.
Free recall was most accurate.
Leading or misleading questions produced less accurate answers.
William Stern (1910): created the “reality experiment” using staged dramatic events.
Eyewitness accuracy decreased under stress and emotional arousal.
Albert von Schrenck-Notzing (1896): first psychologist to testify as an expert witness.
Described “retroactive memory falsification,” in which witnesses confuse actual memories with information later reported in the media.
Hugo Munsterberg:
Wrote On the Witness Stand (1908).
Suggested psychology could improve eyewitness testimony, detect lies and false confessions, explain suggestibility and hypnotism, and help prevent crime.
John Henry Wigmore (1909) criticised Munsterberg for overstating psychology’s powers and lacking evidence.
Overall importance: these studies established that memory can be influenced by questioning, stress, emotional arousal, and outside information, and helped introduce psychology into legal decision-making.
Social disorganization theory
Explains crime as a result of weakened community institutions, relationships, and informal social controls.
Originated in the Chicago School of Sociology.
Shaw and McKay (1942) found that crime was concentrated in neighbourhoods marked by instability and disadvantage.
Park and Burgess (1925) proposed concentric zones:
Central Business District.
Zone of transition: poor housing, high mobility, immigration, and high crime.
Working-class housing.
Middle-class residential areas.
Commuter/suburban zones.
Crime was highest in the zone of transition regardless of which ethnic group lived there, suggesting that place and conditions mattered more than ethnicity.
Causes of disorganization:
Poverty.
Residential mobility.
Ethnic heterogeneity.
Family disruption.
These factors reduce collective efficacy, or neighbours’ shared willingness to supervise and protect the community.
Strengths:
Explains neighbourhood crime hotspots.
Supports community policing, neighbourhood watches, and urban renewal.
Shifts attention from “bad people” to harmful environments.
Criticisms:
Does not explain why many people in disorganised areas remain law-abiding.
Early versions could be ethnocentric and culturally biased.
Mainly explains street crime, not white-collar or cybercrime.
May overlook cultural strengths in high-crime communities.
Strain and anomie theories
Robert K. Merton published his strain theory in 1938.
Anomie, a term associated with Émile Durkheim, means normlessness or lack of moral standards.
Merton argued that crime results from a gap between culturally approved goals and legitimate means of achieving them.
The “American Dream” encourages financial and material success, but people do not have equal access to education, jobs, money, or social connections.
When legitimate opportunities are blocked, some people may use illegal means.
Merton’s five adaptations
Conformity: accepts cultural goals and legitimate means.
Innovation: accepts success goals but uses illegitimate means because legitimate opportunities are blocked.
Ritualism: gives up on the success goals but continues following conventional means.
Retreatism: rejects both the goals and the legitimate means and withdraws from society.
Rebellion: rejects existing goals and means and tries to replace them with new ones.
General Strain Theory
Developed by Robert Agnew.
Crime can result from:
Failure to achieve important goals.
Loss of something valued.
Exposure to harmful or negative experiences.
Strain may produce anger, frustration, or stress, which can motivate crime as a coping response.
GST applies to more than poverty-related financial crime.
Not everyone under strain offends; coping skills, support, personal values, and social controls affect outcomes.
Criticisms of strain theory:
Early versions focused too narrowly on financial crime and lower socioeconomic groups.
Does not fully explain different individual responses to strain.
Limited empirical support in some versions.
Does not adequately explain differences by gender and ethnicity.
Social learning theory
Associated with Albert Bandura and Alfred Bandura and Richard Walters.
People can learn criminal or aggressive behaviour by observing and associating with others.
Crime is more likely to continue when it produces rewards such as money, excitement, status, or peer approval and punishment is infrequent.
Learning can occur without an immediate visible change in behaviour.
Bobo doll experiments
Children observed an adult model aggressively hitting and scolding a Bobo doll.
Many children later imitated the aggressive behaviour.
Boys showed more aggression overall and were especially influenced by male models; girls were also influenced by same-sex models.
Children who saw live, filmed, or cartoon versions showed similar imitation.
Children who saw the model punished later displayed much less aggression.
Observing rewards does not always produce imitation, but observing punishment can reduce imitation.
Five key principles
Learning is a cognitive process occurring in a social setting.
People can learn by observing behaviour and its consequences.
Learning can occur without an observable behavioural change.
Reinforcement influences learning but is not the only cause.
Cognition, behaviour, and environment influence one another; this is reciprocal determinism.
Early biological theories
Degeneration theory
B. A. Morel proposed a theory of progressive degeneration in 1857.
Claimed that inherited physical and moral deterioration made some social classes and races more vulnerable to illness and crime.
Associated substance use with deterioration passed across generations.
Influenced Lombroso and later eugenic ideas.
Modern evaluation: scientifically discredited and criticised for classism, racism, stigma, and unsupported assumptions about inherited moral weakness.
Lombroso’s atavistic theory
Cesare Lombroso proposed the theory in The Criminal Man (1876).
Claimed some people were “born criminals” and were evolutionary throwbacks.
Suggested criminals could be identified by physical characteristics.
Examples in the module include different alleged features for thieves, murderers, sex offenders, and female criminals.
Main problem: physical appearance cannot reliably identify criminality and the theory reinforced stereotypes.
Somatotype theory
Ernst Kretschmer linked body type with personality and mental illness:
Asthenic/leptosomatic: slim and fragile; linked with introversion and schizophrenia.
Pyknic: round and short; linked with sociability and manic-depressive tendencies.
Athletic: muscular; linked with assertiveness and epilepsy.
William Sheldon (1942) proposed:
Ectomorph: thin and sensitive; quiet and introverted.
Endomorph: rounded and soft; relaxed, sociable, and peaceful.
Mesomorph: muscular and solid; aggressive, adventurous, assertive, and risk-taking.
Sheldon reported that many criminals were mesomorphs.
Possible explanations included physical capacity for confrontation and stereotyping by society or police.
Criticisms:
Ignores environment and social factors.
Uses limited and biased samples.
Reinforces stereotypes and police bias.
Modern criminology treats it as historical rather than an adequate explanation.
Genetics and criminal behaviour
There is no single “criminal gene.”
Genetic factors may predispose people to impulsivity, aggression, low empathy, or poor emotional regulation.
These vulnerabilities interact with poverty, abuse, peer influence, rejection, and other environmental factors.
XYY syndrome
Typical humans have 46 chromosomes; XYY males have 47, including an extra Y chromosome.
Occurs in about 1 in 1,000 male births.
Early “supermale” claims suggested XYY males were especially violent or sexually aggressive.
Jacobs and colleagues (1965) studied 315 male patients in a Scottish high-security hospital and found 7 with XYY, along with tendencies toward greater height, lower IQ, and aggressive or antisocial behaviour.
Later evidence showed:
Many XYY men are peaceful and law-abiding.
Developmental, language, learning, and social difficulties may increase vulnerability to delinquency indirectly.
The extra Y chromosome does not directly cause crime.
Criticisms:
Early prison samples were small and biased.
The theory overemphasised violence.
Labelling creates stigma and discrimination.
It focused mainly on men and neglected social environment.
Family, twin, and adoption studies
Family studies cannot separate genes from shared environment.
Identical twins share nearly all genes; fraternal twins share about half.
Higher concordance in identical twins suggests genetic influence, but shared upbringing remains a limitation.
MISTRA, the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, found strong similarities in IQ, personality, temperament, interests, and behaviour among identical twins raised separately; it strongly supports genetic influence but does not prove a direct genetic cause of crime.
Adoption studies often find more antisocial tendencies among children whose biological parents offended, even when adoptive families were not criminal.
Adoption evidence suggests genetic influence but cannot eliminate differences in prenatal conditions or adoptive environments.
Jeffrey Landrigan case
Defence arguments referred to a biological father convicted of murder and possible prenatal substance-related brain damage.
Landrigan had behavioural problems, substance abuse, imprisonment, and later committed murders.
Genetic and prenatal factors were presented as possible mitigating evidence.
The case illustrates a legal dilemma: biological evidence might reduce blame, but it might also be used to portray someone as permanently dangerous.
Overall conclusion: genes create vulnerability, but crime develops through interaction among biology, psychology, environment, and society.
Biochemical explanations
Modern biological explanations treat aggression as biosocial: biology and environment interact.
Important factors include hormones, neurotransmitters, genes, brain structures, and substances.
Brain regions
Prefrontal cortex:
Decision-making, planning, attention, impulse control, and moral reasoning.
Deficits may produce poor judgement, impulsivity, aggression, and failure to anticipate consequences.
Limbic system, including amygdala and hippocampus:
Emotion, fear, aggression, memory, and empathy.
Abnormal functioning may reduce fear conditioning and responsiveness to punishment.
Crime may involve disrupted communication between emotional limbic systems and controlling prefrontal systems.
Neurotransmitters
Dopamine:
Reward, pleasure, motivation, and sensation-seeking.
Excess may increase impulsivity, risk-taking, substance misuse, and thrill crime.
Norepinephrine:
Arousal, attention, and stress response.
High levels may produce irritability and aggressive overreaction.
Low levels may produce under-arousal, emotional blunting, and low fear.
Serotonin:
Regulates mood, impulse control, and aggression.
Low serotonin is associated with impulsive violence and poor anger control.
It functions like a neural “brake” on destructive impulses.
Important studies
Raine et al. (1997): PET scans of 41 murderers showed reduced prefrontal activity and abnormal limbic functioning compared with controls.
Raine et al. (2000): MRI research found about 11% less prefrontal grey matter in people with antisocial personality disorder.
Moffitt (1990): life-course-persistent offenders often show childhood attention, learning, and impulse-control problems that interact with adverse environments.
Ishikawa and Raine (2003): offenders with antisocial traits performed worse on planning, foresight, and impulse-control tests.
Wagner et al. (1980): castration reduced aggression in mice and testosterone restored aggression in previously aggressive mice; testosterone alone did not make non-aggressive mice violent.
Basal model: testosterone directly produces dominance and aggression.
Reciprocal model: dominance and winning can themselves increase testosterone, while losing may reduce it.
Mann et al. (1990): reducing serotonin increased hostility, especially in people with previous aggressive tendencies.
Coccaro et al. (1989): violent psychiatric patients had a blunted prolactin response after a serotonin-stimulating drug, indicating underactive serotonin systems.
Brunner et al. (1993): a rare MAOA mutation in a Dutch family was associated with impulsive aggression; the mutation did not prove that all aggression is genetic.
Lavine (1997): stimulant drugs that raise dopamine and norepinephrine were linked with increased aggression.
Alcohol lowers inhibition and impairs judgement, making people more likely to misread threats and act aggressively.
Research discussed in the module links alcohol-related aggression with gender, body size, cultural beliefs, and perceived social permission.
Criticisms and biosocial conclusion
Animal findings may not generalise to complex human aggression.
Biological explanations can be reductionist if they ignore poverty, culture, peers, trauma, and inequality.
Correlation does not prove causation; biological changes may sometimes result from aggressive behaviour rather than cause it.
Biological evidence in court can reduce blame or increase perceptions of dangerousness.
“Born criminal” claims risk stigma, discrimination, and fatalism.
The biosocial model is the preferred modern position:
Biology creates vulnerabilities.
Environment and social experiences influence whether vulnerabilities become criminal behaviour.
Early family support, education, therapy, and social intervention may reduce risk.
Neurological theories and neuropsychology
Modern neurological theories use brain imaging, neuropsychological tests, and brain-chemistry research rather than visible physical features.
They focus on brain systems involved in impulse control, empathy, decision-making, and emotional regulation.
Head injuries are more common among some offender groups, but the direction of causation is unclear:
Brain injury may increase risk.
Risky or violent lifestyles may increase the chance of receiving a head injury.
Evidence concerning chromosomal abnormalities, developmental delays, and brain structure is inconsistent.
Methodological problems include weak control groups and difficulty separating biological from social causes.
Ethical concern: it is unjust and dangerous to label everyone with a brain injury or abnormality as a potential criminal.
Conclusion: neurological factors may increase vulnerability but cannot fully predict criminal behaviour.
Brain and behaviour case comparisons
Phineas Gage:
Frontal-lobe injury changed a responsible worker into someone impulsive, aggressive, and socially inappropriate.
Demonstrates the importance of the frontal lobe for personality and self-control.
Charles Whitman:
A brain tumour affected the area near the amygdala.
His case suggested a possible biological contribution to violent behaviour.
Neither case proves that brain injury or tumours automatically cause crime.
Evolutionary psychology and crime
Traits that help survival or reproduction may be inherited.
What may be inherited are tendencies such as aggression, impulsivity, low empathy, or manipulation—not specific crimes.
Competition for resources and mates may have selected some aggressive or exploitative strategies.
Psychopathic manipulation has been discussed as a possible exploitative strategy.
Evolutionary explanations of sexual violence are criticised for being too simplistic; sexual violence may involve control, power, and humiliation rather than reproduction.
Evolutionary psychology alone cannot explain criminal behaviour.
Intelligence and crime
The claim that low intelligence directly causes crime is too simple.
Lower measured IQ may be associated with:
Poor school performance and dropout.
Unemployment or unstable work.
Weak communication and conflict-management skills.
More contact with police and legal authorities.
These social disadvantages can increase exposure to crime and detection, creating an apparent IQ–crime relationship.
Guay et al. (2005) found chronic offenders scored about 8 IQ points lower than non-offenders, but the overall correlation was weak.
Most people with low IQ are not criminals, and many criminals have average or above-average IQ.
IQ tests may be culturally biased and may not measure emotional intelligence, social awareness, or practical abilities.
Low IQ may contribute to poor problem-solving and impulse control, but social context remains essential.
Steven Steinberg case:
A middle-class man killed his wife and claimed unconscious rage.
Evaluations suggested average-to-low IQ and poor impulse control.
The defence argued that the killing reflected psychological breakdown rather than premeditation.
The case shows that low cognitive ability alone does not explain violence; stress, self-control, personality, and situation also matter.
Eysenck’s biological personality theory
Hans Eysenck argued that personality consists of relatively stable, partly inherited traits.
Main dimensions:
Extraversion–introversion.
Neuroticism–stability.
Psychoticism–normality.
Together these form the PEN model, measured using the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire.
Criminals were expected to score higher on traits linked with excitement-seeking, emotional instability, aggression, impulsivity, and low empathy.
Biological explanations of the traits
Extraversion: linked to the reticular activating system; under-arousal may produce a need for extra stimulation.
Neuroticism: linked to the autonomic nervous system and greater emotional arousal to stress.
Psychoticism: linked in the module to dopamine activity, reward-seeking, aggression, and reduced concern for others.
Criticisms
Does not explain different types of crime.
Research findings are mixed; psychoticism and neuroticism are more consistently linked with crime than extraversion.
Personality tests may not measure traits perfectly.
Social factors such as poverty, peers, and environment may be more important than the theory suggests.
Psychoanalytic theories of criminal behaviour
Freud’s personality structure:
Id: immediate gratification of hunger, sex, aggression, and other urges.
Ego: manages reality and balances competing demands.
Superego: moral conscience formed through parents and society.
Strong id plus weak superego may lead to impulsive, selfish, or criminal acts.
Incomplete superego development may resemble psychopathy or sociopathy because guilt, empathy, and remorse are weak.
Harsh physical discipline may backfire by teaching that aggression is an acceptable way to solve problems.
Conflict among the id, ego, and superego can create anxiety.
Defence mechanisms such as repression, projection, denial, and displacement may turn unresolved conflict into antisocial behaviour.
Erikson’s identity-crisis idea:
Adolescents who cannot form a stable identity may seek belonging through deviant peers, gangs, or crime.
Oedipus-complex explanation:
Children identify with role models and internalise their values.
A criminal parent or role model may contribute to antisocial moral development.
Childhood trauma, neglect, and deviant role models may interfere with empathy and moral development.
Criticisms
Unconscious processes are difficult to measure scientifically.
The theory can pathologise crime and overlook rational choices.
It overemphasises childhood; not all offenders experience trauma and not all traumatised people offend.
Poverty, peers, opportunity, culture, and social conditions are underemphasised.
Overall exam conclusion
No single theory explains every crime or every offender.
Social theories explain community conditions, inequality, strain, learning, and labelling.
Biological theories explain vulnerabilities involving genes, brain systems, hormones, neurotransmitters, and substances.
Psychological theories explain personality, cognition, impulse control, development, learning, and unconscious conflict.
The strongest overall conclusion is an interactionist/biosocial one: criminal behaviour emerges from the interaction of individual vulnerabilities, learning and personality, social environment, culture, opportunities, and immediate situations.
A risk factor is not a destiny or a direct cause; it increases vulnerability but does not guarantee offending.